Skip to content

Logic Artifact Re-Inspection Report (v1.1) ​

Report Metadata ​

FieldValue
Rule setSanityOps Framework v1.1
Inspection scopeInspect (Prompt, Skill, Tool, Cross, Permission) + Risk Explicit
Out of scopeRisk Implicit (requires shadow sandbox + LLM API), Quality (requires runtime execution)
Artifacts inspectedenergy-management-assistant.md, freight-logistics-assistant.md, medication-information-assistant.md
Inspection date2026-11-02
MethodStatic re-scan against the L1 sub-specifications

Rule-version note: the historical "PASS (0 P0 defects)" recorded in each artifact reflects the v1.0 rule set and sanityops-cli v0.1.5. This is a static re-scan under v1.1; it does not modify the artifacts, and it adjudicates only the checks described below. Risk Implicit (A/B/C/D termination) and Quality (RAG-Agent / Tool-Agent) are runtime validations and are therefore not re-run here (core.md §1.4: the three subsets are independent and non-substitutable).


1. Scope and Method ​

The three artifacts are "Fixed Artifacts" — post-remediation snapshots of System Prompts, Skills (SKILL.md), and Tool parameter schemas. Each was re-inspected against:

  • Inspect Prompt (QD-P-*) — logic defects and explicit-prompt checklist defects
  • Inspect Skill (QD-S-*) — resource runaway, unbounded directives, ambiguity, failure escalation, permission overflow
  • Inspect Tool (QD-T-*) — structural validity, parameter constraints, high-risk operations, semantic clarity
  • Inspect Cross (QD-PS / QD-PT / QD-ST / QD-CYC) — Prompt↔Skill↔Tool contract and circular invocation
  • Inspect Permission (QD-PM-*) — responsibility–authority proportionality (run last)
  • Risk Explicit (EX-*, NL-A/B, NR-O/S) — statically readable dangerous content

All three agents are read-only assistants over local sample datasets (no write/delete/external side effects). This materially limits the severity ceiling of most findings.


2. Summary Table ​

ArtifactFindingsP0P1Gate
Energy Management Assistant303PASS (P1 to fix)
Freight Logistics Assistant101PASS (P1 to fix)
Medication Information Assistant202PASS (P1 to fix)

No P0 defect was confirmed in any artifact. Gate-0 pre-check and Permission proportionality pass. Risk Explicit reports zero findings.


3. Energy Management Assistant ​

F-1 · QD-PS-1.5 — Failure-handling contradiction (retry strategy) · P1 ​

Location: Prompt "Tool Invocation Specification" item 3 vs. Skill "Failure Handling Policy".

Evidence:

  • Prompt: "On error, quote the error message to the user and ask for corrected inputs. Do not retry the same call more than once with identical parameters."
  • energy_analysis Skill: "you may retry the identical call at most 3 times (per max_retries); if the retry also fails, stop immediately."
  • efficiency_optimization / renewable_integration Skills (front matter max_retries: 3, but body): "If a tool call fails … stop immediately … Do not attempt alternatives."

Assessment: Three mutually inconsistent retry policies coexist — the Prompt caps retries at 1 (identical parameters), the energy_analysis skill permits 3 identical retries, and the other two skills instruct "stop immediately" (0 retries) despite declaring max_retries: 3 in their front matter. Per inspect/cross.md QD-PS-1.5 this is a failure-handling strategy inconsistency. Graded P1 because all affected tools are read-only and idempotent, so the worst consequence is bounded call amplification rather than data loss.

Remediation: Unify the retry policy to a single source (defer to the Prompt); align max_retries in each Skill front matter with the chosen value, and remove the contradictory "retry the identical call 3 times" wording.

F-2 · QD-PS-1.6 — Mandatory disclaimer wording mismatch · P1 ​

Location: Prompt "Principle 1" rule 1 vs. efficiency_optimization Skill "Important Constraints".

Evidence:

  • Prompt (authoritative statement, explicitly marked "the single authoritative statement of the disclaimer; other sections refer to it but do not restate the wording"): "⚠️ This recommendation requires review and approval by licensed engineering staff before implementation."
  • efficiency_optimization Skill: "Always include the safety disclaimer: '⚠️ This recommendation requires review and approval by qualified engineering staff before implementation.'"

Assessment: The Skill both restates the verbatim-required phrase (against the Prompt's explicit "do not restate" instruction) and substitutes "qualified" for "licensed". For a safety-critical verbatim phrase this is an output-constraint inconsistency between Prompt and Skill.

Remediation: Have the Skill reference the Prompt's authoritative wording instead of restating it, and correct the wording if retained.

F-3 · QD-PT-2.7 — Parameter unit/currency caliber inconsistency · P1 ​

Location: Prompt "Authorized Tools" vs. efficiency_optimization Skill parameter description.

Evidence:

  • Prompt: budget_constraint — "(number, USD, 0-10,000,000)".
  • Skill: budget_constraint — "Maximum implementation budget in local currency (0-10,000,000)".

Assessment: The same parameter is declared in USD on the Prompt side and "local currency" on the Skill side — a semantic caliber mismatch for a monetary input. Graded P1 (no write operation involving funds is performed; the tool is read-only, so the P0 instance upgrade for fund-bearing writes does not apply).

Remediation: Unify to the Tool's authoritative inputSchema description ("local currency") or correct the Prompt table to match.


4. Freight Logistics Assistant ​

F-1 · QD-PS-1.5 — Failure-handling contradiction (retry strategy) · P1 ​

Location: Prompt "Tool Invocation Specification" item 3 vs. all three Skills' "Failure Handling Policy".

Evidence:

  • Prompt: "You may retry the same call at most once with corrected parameters; never retry with identical parameters."
  • freight_quotation / route_planning / shipment_tracking Skills: "You may retry the identical call at most 3 times (per max_retries); if the retry also fails, stop immediately."

Assessment: The Prompt permits at most one retry and prohibits retrying with identical parameters; every Skill permits three retries of the identical call. This is the sharpest form of the retry-strategy contradiction (the "never retry identical" directive directly conflicts with "retry the identical call 3 times"). It is graded P1 rather than P0 because all tools are read-only and idempotent, so the worst consequence is bounded call amplification, not data loss or irreversible side effects.

Remediation: Unify retry count and the identical-vs-corrected parameter rule to a single authority (defer to the Prompt), and align each Skill's max_retries.


5. Medication Information Assistant ​

F-1 · QD-PS-1.5 — Failure-handling contradiction (retry strategy) · P1 ​

Location: Prompt "Tool Invocation Specification" item 3 vs. medication_info Skill front matter and "Failure Handling Policy".

Evidence:

  • Prompt: "On error … tell the user the lookup failed … Do not retry the identical call."
  • medication_info Skill front matter: max_retries: 3.
  • medication_info Skill body: "If a tool call fails or returns an error, stop immediately and report the error to the user. Do not attempt alternative tools."

Assessment: The Skill's own max_retries: 3 front-matter declaration contradicts both its body ("stop immediately", no retry) and the Prompt ("do not retry the identical call"). Read-only idempotent tools cap the impact at P1.

Remediation: Remove or reconcile the stray max_retries: 3 front-matter field so it matches the "no retry" policy stated in the Prompt and Skill body.

F-2 · QD-ST-3.5 (with QD-P-1.4.1 redundancy) — Duplicate and inconsistent output enumeration for medication_check_interactions · P1 ​

Location: medication_info Skill, operation 3 "Returns (closed enumeration)" vs. tools/medication_check_interactions.py docstring.

Evidence (Skill, verbatim):

Returns (closed enumeration - do not add extra fields):

  • interactions_found: Boolean, true when at least one interaction was detected
  • interactions: List of identified interactions (empty list when none found), each with only: severity, type, description, recommendation
  • interactions_found: Boolean, true when at least one interaction was detected
  • interactions: List of found interactions (see below)
  • summary: One-sentence summary

Tool docstring: "Returns data.interactions_found …, data.interactions …, data.medications_checked, data.foods_included, and data.summary."

Assessment:

  1. The Skill enumerates interactions_found and interactions twice, once with the full field contract and once as a shorthand — a structural redundancy/self-contradiction in a "closed enumeration" (QD-P-1.4.1, ungraded suggestion; the closed contract is destabilized).
  2. The Skill's enumeration omits medications_checked and foods_included, which the Tool docstring declares as returned fields — an output-structure mismatch between Skill and Tool (QD-ST-3.5, P1).

Remediation: Collapse the duplicate Returns block into a single enumeration and add medications_checked / foods_included (or explicitly exclude them if the skill's contract intentionally narrows the presented fields, in which case the wording should say so).


6. Risk Explicit ​

No EX findings across the three artifacts. Specifically reviewed for:

  • NR-S-9 hardcoded credentials / secrets — none present (emission factors and pricing rates are data, not credentials).
  • NR-S-5 tool-description instruction poisoning — none present.
  • NL-A / NL-B embedded dangerous directives — none present.

Result: PASS (0 EX findings).

7. Permission (QD-PM) ​

All three agents declare read-only operations, explicit prohibited operations (write/update/delete/insert/overwrite/DROP), a bounded list of local data files, no external systems, and explicit chained-invocation restrictions. Responsibility baselines are discriminative (clear Task Boundary / non-goals). No permission exists that is unexplained by, or exceeds, its responsibility baseline.

Result: PASS (proportional; no OR-L3 write/delete/exfiltrate surface).


8. Gate Conclusion ​

StageEnergyFreightMedication
Inspect — Prompt / Skill / ToolPASSPASSPASS
Inspect — CrossP1 (F-1, F-2, F-3)P1 (F-1)P1 (F-1, F-2)
Inspect — PermissionPASSPASSPASS
Risk ExplicitPASSPASSPASS
Static GatePASS (P1 → fix)PASS (P1 → fix)PASS (P1 → fix)

Overall: No P0 defect was confirmed, so the static Gate is PASS for all three artifacts under v1.1. The re-scan surfaces six P1 findings (one cross-cutting retry-strategy contradiction shared by all three, plus three agent-specific contract inconsistencies) that SHOULD be fixed before release per inspect/cross.md remediation ownership.

Not adjudicated here: Risk Implicit (shadow-sandbox runtime validation) and Quality (RAG-Agent / Tool-Agent runtime gates). A complete v1.1 release conclusion would additionally require those two runtime stages, which are out of scope for a static re-scan (core.md §1.4, §6.1).